Eccentric muscle actions do not promote superior hypertrophy compared with concentric actions
a systematic review and meta-analysis
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.51224/SRXIV.401Keywords:
muscle growth, shortening, lengthening, strength trainingAbstract
Different physiological mechanisms of sarcomere activity during eccentric (ECC) and concentric (CON) muscle actions led to investigations into muscle hypertrophy outcomes, but conclusions remain elusive. We aimed to investigate the effects of ECC vs. CON muscle actions on muscle hypertrophy in apparently healthy adults through a systematic review with meta-analysis. The searches were conducted on EMBASE, MedLine, Cochrane Library, Web of Science, Scopus, and SPORTSDiscus databases. Eligibility criteria: blinded and unblinded randomized controlled trials that investigated the effects of CON versus ECC resistance training programs in apparently healthy adults (≥18 years old). These studies should have performed hypertrophy measurements in outcomes using cross-sectional area, muscle thickness, or muscle volume assessed by imaging methods. 15778 studies were identified, and twenty-six (682 participants included in the meta-analysis) achieved the inclusion criteria. The main findings indicate that: there was no difference between ECC vs. CON on hypertrophy measurements (0.285 [95%CI: -0.131 to 0.701]; p= 0.179; I2: 84.4%; GRADE: Very low). Subgroup meta-analysis analyzing possible hypertrophy outcome moderators as age (18 to 59 years old and ≥60 years old) and weeks of intervention duration (≤8 weeks and >8 weeks) did not reveal differences between ECC vs. CON. Sub-group analysis revealed a very limited but significant effect for ECC on the upper limb muscles (1.44 [95%CI: 0.179 to 2692]; p= 0.025; I2: 91%; GRADE: Low). Our findings suggest there was no evidence of a difference in hypertrophy between ECC and CON muscle action in apparently healthy adults.
Metrics
References
Ardern, CL, Büttner, F, Andrade, R, et al. Implementing the 27 PRISMA 2020 Statement items for systematic reviews in the sport and exercise medicine, musculoskeletal rehabilitation and sports science fields: the PERSiST (implementing Prisma in Exercise, Rehabilitation, Sport medicine and SporTs science) guidance. Br J Sports Med 56: 175–195, 2022.
Baptista, R, Onzi, E, Goulart, N, et al. Effects of Concentric Versus Eccentric Strength Training on the Elderly’s Knee Extensor Structure and Function. Journal of Exercise Physiology Online 19: 120–132, 2016.
Benford, J, Hughes, J, Waldron, M, and Theis, N. Concentric versus eccentric training: Effect on muscle strength, regional morphology, and architecture. Translational Sports Medicine 4: 46–55, 2021.
Blazevich, AJ, Cannavan, D, Coleman, DR, and Horne, S. Influence of concentric and eccentric resistance training on architectural adaptation in human quadriceps muscles. Journal of Applied Physiology 103: 1565–1575, 2007.
Brandenburg, JP and Docherty, D. The effects of accentuated eccentric loading on strength, muscle hypertrophy, and neural adaptations in trained individuals. J Strength Cond Res 16: 25–32, 2002.
Brynnel, A, Hernandez, Y, Kiss, B, et al. Downsizing the molecular spring of the giant protein titin reveals that skeletal muscle titin determines passive stiffness and drives longitudinal hypertrophy. eLife 7: e40532, 2018.
Buker, N, Savkin, R, Suzer, A, and Akkaya, N. Effect of eccentric and concentric squat exercise on quadriceps thickness and lower extremity performance in healthy young males. ACTA GYMNICA 51, 2021.
Cadore, EL, González-Izal, M, Pallarés, JG, et al. Muscle conduction velocity, strength, neural activity, and morphological changes after eccentric and concentric training. Scandinavian Journal of Medicine and Science in Sports 24: e343–e352, 2014.
Caserotti, P, Aagaard, P, and Puggaard, L. Changes in power and force generation during coupled eccentric-concentric versus concentric muscle contraction with training and aging. Eur J Appl Physiol 103: 151–161, 2008.
Coratella, G, Beato, M, Bertinato, L, et al. Including the Eccentric Phase in Resistance Training to Counteract the Effects of Detraining in Women: A Randomized Controlled Trial. Journal of strength and conditioning research 36: 3023–3031, 2022.
Coratella, G and Schena, F. Eccentric resistance training increases and retains maximal strength, muscle endurance, and hypertrophy in trained men. Appl Physiol Nutr Metab 41: 1184–1189, 2016.
Douglas, J, Pearson, S, Ross, A, and McGuigan, M. Chronic Adaptations to Eccentric Training: A Systematic Review. Sports Med 47: 917–941, 2017.
Duhig, SJ, Bourne, MN, Buhmann, RL, et al. Effect of concentric and eccentric hamstring training on sprint recovery, strength and muscle architecture in inexperienced athletes. Journal of Science and Medicine in Sport 22: 769–774, 2019.
Fang, Y, Siemionow, V, Sahgal, V, Xiong, F, and Yue, GH. Distinct brain activation patterns for human maximal voluntary eccentric and concentric muscle actions. Brain Research 1023: 200–212, 2004.
Farthing, JP and Chilibeck, PD. The effects of eccentric and concentric training at different velocities on muscle hypertrophy. European Journal of Applied Physiology 89: 578–586, 2003.
Farup, J, Rahbek, S, Vendelbo, M, et al. Whey protein hydrolysate augments tendon and muscle hypertrophy independent of resistance exercise contraction mode. Scandinavian journal of medicine & science in sports 24: 788–798, 2014.
Franchi, MV, Atherton, PJ, Reeves, ND, et al. Architectural, functional and molecular responses to concentric and eccentric loading in human skeletal muscle. ACTA PHYSIOLOGICA 210: 642–654, 2014.
Häkkinen, K, Newton, RU, Walker, S, et al. Effects of Upper Body Eccentric versus Concentric Strength Training and Detraining on Maximal Force, Muscle Activation, Hypertrophy and Serum Hormones in Women. Journal of Sports Science & Medicine 21: 200–213, 2022.
Haun, CT, Vann, CG, Roberts, BM, et al. A Critical Evaluation of the Biological Construct Skeletal Muscle Hypertrophy: Size Matters but So Does the Measurement. Front Physiol 10: 247, 2019.
Herzog, W. The mysteries of eccentric muscle action. J Sport Health Sci 7: 253–254, 2018.
Herzog, W. The multiple roles of titin in muscle contraction and force production. Biophys Rev 10: 1187–1199, 2018.
Herzog, W, Schappacher, G, DuVall, M, Leonard, TR, and Herzog, JA. Residual Force Enhancement Following Eccentric Contractions: A New Mechanism Involving Titin. Physiology 31: 300–312, 2016.
Higbie, EJ, Cureton, KJ, Warren III, GL, and Prior, BM. Effects of concentric and eccentric training on muscle strength, cross-sectional area, and neural activation. Journal of applied physiology 81: 2173–2181, 1996.
Higgins, J, Thomas, J, Chandler, J, et al. Cochrane Handbook for Systematic Reviews of Interventions. Cochrane Handbook for Systematic Reviews of Interventions , 2019.
Higgins, JP, Li, T, and Deeks, J. Choosing effect measures and computing estimates of effect. In: Cochrane Handbook for Systematic Reviews of Interventions version 6.3.Cochrane, 2022.Available from: http://www.training.cochrane.org/handbook
Jones, D and Rutherford, O. Human muscle strength training: the effects of three different regimens and the nature of the resultant changes. The Journal of physiology 391: 1–11, 1987.
Kidgell, DJ, Frazer, AK, Rantalainen, T, et al. Increased cross-education of muscle strength and reduced corticospinal inhibition following eccentric strength training. Neuroscience 300: 566–575, 2015.
Kim, DY, Oh, SL, and Lim, J-Y. Applications of Eccentric Exercise to Improve Muscle and Mobility Function in Older Adults. Ann Geriatr Med Res 26: 4–15, 2022.
Kim, SY, Ko, JB, Farthing, JP, and Butcher, SJ. Investigation of supraspinatus muscle architecture following concentric and eccentric training. Journal of science and medicine in sport 18: 378–382, 2015.
LaStayo, P, Marcus, R, Dibble, L, Frajacomo, F, and Lindstedt, S. Eccentric exercise in rehabilitation: safety, feasibility, and application. Journal of Applied Physiology 116: 1426–1434, 2014.
Maeo, S, Shan, X, Otsuka, S, Kanehisa, H, and Kawakami, Y. Neuromuscular adaptations to work-matched maximal eccentric versus concentric training. Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise 50: 1629–1640, 2018.
Maroto-Izquierdo, S, Martín-Rivera, F, Nosaka, K, et al. Effects of submaximal and supramaximal accentuated eccentric loading on mass and function. Front Physiol 14: 1176835, 2023.
Meader, N, King, K, Llewellyn, A, et al. A checklist designed to aid consistency and reproducibility of GRADE assessments: development and pilot validation. Syst Rev 3: 82, 2014.
Moore, DR, Young, M, and Phillips, SM. Similar increases in muscle size and strength in young men after training with maximal shortening or lengthening contractions when matched for total work. European Journal of Applied Physiology 112: 1587–1592, 2012.
Nuzzo, JL, Pinto, MD, Nosaka, K, and Steele, J. The Eccentric:Concentric Strength Ratio of Human Skeletal Muscle In Vivo: Meta-analysis of the Influences of Sex, Age, Joint Action, and Velocity. Sports Med 53: 1125–1136, 2023.
Osternig, LR. Isokinetic dynamometry: implications for muscle testing and rehabilitation. Exerc Sport Sci Rev 14: 45–80, 1986.
Page, MJ, McKenzie, JE, Bossuyt, PM, et al. The PRISMA 2020 statement: an updated guideline for reporting systematic reviews. BMJ 372: n71, 2021.
Pollard, CW, Opar, DA, Williams, MD, Bourne, MN, and Timmins, RG. Razor hamstring curl and Nordic hamstring exercise architectural adaptations: Impact of exercise selection and intensity. Scand J Med Sci Sports 29: 706–715, 2019.
Quinlan, JI, Franchi, MV, Gharahdaghi, N, et al. Muscle and tendon adaptations to moderate load eccentric vs. concentric resistance exercise in young and older males. GeroScience 43: 1567–1584, 2021.
Rosenthal, R. Meta-Analytic Procedures for Social Research. 2455 Teller Road, Thousand Oaks California 91320 United States of America: SAGE Publications, Inc., 1991 [cited 2023 Jan 2].Available from: https://methods.sagepub.com/book/meta-analytic-procedures-for-social-research
Ruas, CV, Pinto, RS, Haff, GG, Lima, CD, and Brown, LE. Article effects of different combinations of concentric and eccentric resistance training programs on traditional and alternative hamstrings-to-quadriceps ratios. Sports 7, 2019.Available from: https://www.scopus.com/inward/record.uri?eid=2-s2.0-85097025614&doi=10.3390%2fsports7100221&partnerID=40&md5=aebda53c4af33a618811192bee4e2de7
Ryschon, TW, Fowler, MD, Wysong, RE, Anthony, A-R, and Balaban, RS. Efficiency of human skeletal muscle in vivo: comparison of isometric, concentric, and eccentric muscle action. Journal of Applied Physiology 83: 867–874, 1997.
Santos Junior, ERT, de Salles, BF, Dias, I, et al. Classification and Determination Model of Resistance Training Status. Strength & Conditioning Journal 43: 77, 2021.
Sato, S, Yoshida, R, Kiyono, R, et al. Cross-education and detraining effects of eccentric vs. concentric resistance training of the elbow flexors. BMC Sports Science, Medicine and Rehabilitation 13, 2021.Available from: https://www.embase.com/search/results?subaction=viewrecord&id=L2013619945&from=export http://dx.doi.org/10.1186/s13102-021-00298-w
Sato, S, Yoshida, R, Murakoshi, F, et al. Comparison between concentric-only, eccentric-only, and concentric–eccentric resistance training of the elbow flexors for their effects on muscle strength and hypertrophy. European Journal of Applied Physiology 122: 2607–2614, 2022.
Schoenfeld, BJ, Ogborn, DI, Vigotsky, AD, Franchi, MV, and Krieger, JW. Hypertrophic Effects of Concentric vs. Eccentric Muscle Actions: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis. J Strength Cond Res 31: 2599–2608, 2017.
Seger, JY, Arvidsson, B, Thorstensson, A, and Seger, JY. Specific effects of eccentric and concentric training on muscle strength and morphology in humans. European journal of applied physiology and occupational physiology 79: 49–57, 1998.
Şenışık, SÇ, Akova, B, Şekir, U, and Gür, H. Effects of Muscle Architecture on Eccentric Exercise Induced Muscle Damage Responses. J Sports Sci Med 20: 655–664, 2021.
Senn, SJ. Overstating the evidence – double counting in meta-analysis and related problems. BMC Med Res Methodol 9: 10, 2009.
Shibata, K, Takizawa, K, Nosaka, K, and Mizuno, M. Effects of Prolonging Eccentric Phase Duration in Parallel Back-Squat Training to Momentary Failure on Muscle Cross-Sectional Area, Squat One Repetition Maximum, and Performance Tests in University Soccer Players. Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research 35: 668–674, 2021.
Shibata, K, Yamaguchi, T, Takizawa, K, and Nosaka, K. Comparison in Repetitions to Failure Between Concentric-Only and Eccentric-Only Dumbbell Arm Curl Exercise at Four Different Relative Intensities. J Strength Cond Res 37: 1754–1760, 2023.
Smart, NA, Waldron, M, Ismail, H, et al. Validation of a new tool for the assessment of study quality and reporting in exercise training studies: TESTEX. Int J Evid Based Healthc 13: 9–18, 2015.
Souron, R, Nosaka, K, and Jubeau, M. Changes in central and peripheral neuromuscular fatigue indices after concentric versus eccentric contractions of the knee extensors. Eur J Appl Physiol 118: 805–816, 2018.
Tecchio, P, Raiteri, BJ, and Hahn, D. Eccentric exercise ≠ eccentric contraction. J Appl Physiol (1985) 136: 954–965, 2024.
Timmins, RG, Ruddy, JD, Presland, J, Maniar, N, and Williams, M. Architectural changes of the biceps femoris long head after concentric or eccentric training. Medicine and science in sports and exercise 48: 499–508, 2015.
Tomalka, A. Eccentric muscle contractions: from single muscle fibre to whole muscle mechanics. Pflugers Arch 475: 421–435, 2023.
Ünlü, G, Çevikol, C, and Melekoğlu, T. Comparison of the Effects of Eccentric, Concentric, and Eccentric-Concentric Isotonic Resistance Training at Two Velocities on Strength and Muscle Hypertrophy. Journal of strength and conditioning research 34: 337–344, 2020.
Vikne, H, Refsnes, PE, Ekmark, M, et al. Muscular performance after concentric and eccentric exercise in trained men. Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise 38: 1770–1781, 2006.
What Works Clearinghouse, I of ES. What Works Clearinghouse procedures handbook, version 4.1. , 2020.Available from: https://ies.ed.gov/ncee/wwc/Handbooks
Wisdom, KM, Delp, SL, and Kuhl, E. Review. Use it or lose it: Multiscale skeletal muscle adaptation to mechanical stimuli. Biomech Model Mechanobiol 14: 195–215, 2015.
Downloads
Additional Files
Posted
Categories
License
Copyright (c) 2024 Leonardo Santos Lopes Da Silva, Leonardo da Silva Gonçalves, Pedro Henrique Alves Campos, Cícero Jonas Rodrigues Benjamim, Márcio Fernando Tasinafo J´unior, Leonardo Coelho Rabello de Lima, Carlos Roberto Bueno Júnior, Charles Phillipe de Lucena Alves (Author)
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
